Category Archives: Architecture

Vanished New York City Art Deco: The Pennsylvania & Capitol Greyhound Terminals

 

 

1930's Greyhound sign.

1930’s Greyhound Lines sign. Image from ClassicCars.com

The 1930’s was an era of glamorous travel. Great Art Deco ocean liners such as the Normandie and Queen Mary criss crossed the Atlantic every other week. Trains like the New York Central’s Twentieth Century Limited and the Santa Fe’s Super Chief sped across the United States. But nobody, then or now, could honestly tell you bus travel even comes close to the glamour of other forms of transportation. Greyhound, in an effort to step up their image, went on a building spree in the 1930’s. Across the United States new modern bus stations sprang up. And in Manhattan, Greyhound built two streamline moderne terminals in the heart of mid-town.

 

Mid-Town Manhattan Bus Terminals

By the early 1930’s eight small bus terminals dotted mid-town Manhattan. In addition to these terminals the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad offered motor coach service from four terminals in mid-town. With B&O trains terminating in Jersey City (at the Central Railroad of New Jersey terminal), the railroad provided shuttle bus service included with their train fare. From the various Manhattan terminals passengers boarded buses that took them to Jersey City via ferry. Once in the terminal the bus drove onto the departing train’s platform. Of the four Manhattan B&O motor coach stations the most elaborate was located in the Chanin Building at Lexington Avenue & 42nd Street.

 

Chanin Building B&O station.

Interior of the Baltimore & Ohio Bus Terminal in the Chanin Building, circa 1929. Image from MCNY.org

 

Another major bus terminal in mid-town, the Dixie Terminal, had a convenient location near Times Square. This terminal received its name from the fact that is was in the basement of the Hotel Dixie. Buses from this terminal were both interurban (long distance) and suburban (servicing NYC bedroom communities.) Check out  this scoutingny.com post for more information about the Dixie Bus Terminal.

 

The Dixie Bus Terminal postcard.

Postcard view of bus entering the 43rd Street ramp into the Dixie Bus Terminal. Image from scoutingny.com.

Greyhound in Manhattan

The largest motor bus company in the United States, Greyhound, combined many franchises under its corporate umbrella. In New York City there were three franchises each with its own terminal. The smallest of the three terminals, the Midtown on West 43rd Street, had streamline moderne elements. Such as the curved window overlooking the bus platforms. But the Midtown was small compared to Greyhound’s two major terminals.

 

The Midtown Bus Terminal in the early 1940's.

The Midtown Bus Terminal at 143 West 43rd Street, circa, 1941. Image from NYPL Digital Collections.

 

The Pennsylvania and the Capitol, Greyhound’s two largest Manhattan franchises,  would construct large and comfortable terminals for their passengers in the mid and late 1930’s. Greyhound continued to use these terminals long after the Port Authority constructed a central terminal to house all the major long distance and suburban bus lines under one roof.

 

Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal

Just across the street from the massive Pennsylvania Station stood the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal. This subsidiary bus line was jointly owned by the Greyhound Corporation and the Pennsylvania Railroad. Opening around 1929 the Pennsylvania Motor Coach Terminal, built a plain, light-colored brick building directly across 33rd Street from the north exit of Pennsylvania Station’s main waiting room. This allowed for easy transfer from trains to buses and vice versa.

 

1st Penn Greyhound Terminal.

The first Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal (circa, 1929), looking south towards 33rd Street and Pennsylvania Station. Image from Don’s Greyhound Bus Memories.

 

By the mid-1930’s Greyhound decided to spruce up their image and replace their terminal with a very modern one. Greyhound hired noted theatre architect Thomas Lamb (1871-1942) to design their new showcase terminal. Lamb’s design incorporated signature Greyhound style elements into the new building, including the trademark dark blue exterior tiles, chromium banding and curved walls. The new terminal was an excellent example of streamline moderne design.

 

Opening day ad from the New York Daily News.

Penn Greyhound Terminal opening day advertisement, New York Daily News, May 23, 1935. Image from Newspapers.com.

 

Upon it’s opening, the new terminal became a model of modern bus terminal design. 275 buses arrived and departed with approximately 5,000 passengers handled daily. By staggering the loading platforms seven buses could be accommodated at one time. Inside the terminal the 200 seat main waiting room provided many conveniences for passengers. These included public telephones, a telegraph office, a magazine stand, baggage room and a large restaurant. And for the first time in the history of bus terminals a dormitory for the drivers. Also equipped in the terminal a  special loud-speaker system announced arriving and departing buses. Decorating the main waiting room were several colorful murals. Above the bus platforms the heavy concrete canopy served a dual purpose. First it protected passengers from rain and snow and second it was used for loading baggage onto the buses. At the time the buses Greyhound carried the luggage on roof racks. One baggage handler would stand on the canopy and hand the luggage down to a handler on the roof of the bus. The canopy is very visible in the photograph below.

 

1936 photo of the Penn Greyhound Terminal.

Famed photographer Bernice Abbott’s 1936 photograph of the Penn Greyhound Terminal. Image from MCNY.org.

With its convenient location between express subway stations at both 7th and 8th Avenues, the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal soon became the busiest bus station in New York City and perhaps the country.

 

The eastern facade of the terminal.

The east facade of the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal looking north towards 34th Street, 1935. Image from MCNY.org

 

And despite the advertisement claims of colorful murals and a large restaurant, the interior design was just slightly more than utilitarian. The ten window ticket counter took up a great deal of the eastern side of the waiting room and a streamline moderne style news stand  stood on the wall next to the entrance for the bus platforms.

 

Interior of the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal looking south toward the 33rd Street entrance.

Crowds jam the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal on May 24, 1946 during a railroad strike. Interior view looking south toward the 33rd Street entrance. (Photo by Victor Twyman/NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)

 

Looking north inside the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal.

Looking north toward 34th Street and the restaurant inside the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal. May 25, 1946. (Photo by Seymour Wally/NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)

 

Bus platform at the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal on 34th Street.

Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal platforms. Nice ceiling lights and wall sconces in an otherwise utilitarian space, September, 1942. Photo from photogrammer.yale.edu.

 

Bus platform at the 34th Street Greyhound Terminal.

Boarding a bus at the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal on 34th Street, September, 1942. Photo from photogrammer.yale.edu.

 

With the great success of the new Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal, Greyhound decided their Capitol Greyhound Terminal needed a new home as well.

 

Color Greyhound ad from the mid-1930's.

A Greyhound advertisement, circa 1936 featuring a color depiction of the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal. Image from Pinterest.

 

 

Capitol Greyhound Terminal

In mid-November, 1930 the Pennsylvania and Eastern Greyhound Lines took over the lease on the Capitol Theatre Bus Terminal. The original terminal was sandwiched between the Capitol Theatre on the east and the Knights of Columbus Hotel at 8th Avenue to the west. And like the Pennsylvania bus terminal, the terminal ran through the block from 50th Street to 51st Street. This new Greyhound subsidiary was named the Capitol Greyhound Bus Terminal. The company also leased the basement, ground, second and third floors of the auditorium in the Knights of Columbus Hotel. The entrance for the Greyhound terminal was on 8th Avenue mid-block between 50th and 51st Streets.

 

8th Avenue in 1936 showing the first Capitol Greyhound Terminal.

The entrance to the Greyhound Terminal is on the left in the view looking south on 8th from 51st. The third Madison Square Garden is on the right in the background, 1936. Image from the NYPL Digital Collections.

 

The loading area of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal, 1933.

The loading and discharging area of the original Capitol Greyhound Terminal. Looking north toward 51st Street, 1933. Image from NYPL Digital Collections.

With the success of the new terminal on 34th Street, Greyhound now wanted a modern bus station for the Capitol Terminal. Once again they reached out to Thomas Lamb and his company to design the new terminal.  It would occupy the area where the buses would pick up and discharge passengers and the site of the building directly east of that location. Construction began in mid-1936.

 

Cross section of the interior.

Capitol Greyhound Cross Section of the interior. The Architectural Record, January, 1937. usmodernist.org

 

First floor plan.

The first floor plan. The Architectural Record, January, 1937. usmodernist.org

Second floor plan.

The second floor plan. The Architectural Record, January, 1937. usmodernist.org

 

The January, 1937 issue of The Architectural Record featured the new Capitol Greyhound Terminal as a model example of bus terminal design. The 88 foot wide building extended through the block from 50th to 51st street. Bus platforms were placed on the east and west sides of the terminal and the concrete platforms were laid out in a saw tooth pattern. Starting in 1937 Greyhound used a bus with an interior luggage compartment, located underneath the passengers and between the wheels. The days of the rooftop luggage rack was over. As a result the platform canopies of the new terminal could be constructed out of relatively thin corrugated metal. Unlike the thick concrete canopy of the 34th Greyhound Terminal.

 

Capitol Greyhound Terminal west side platforms.

The newly remodeled Greyhound Bus Terminal at 50th Street and 8th Avenue, New York, New York, May 12, 1938. The west side platforms. (Photo by Underwood Archives/Getty Images)

Most of the exterior of the building consisted of buff colored bricks on a concrete foundation.

 

Capitol Greyhound Terminal, 1938.

Greyhound bus turning east off 8th Avenue onto 50th street in 1938. The new Capitol Terminal is mid-block directly in front of the bus. Image from thegeorgemanarchive.com

Capitol Greyhound advertisement, New York Times.

New York Times advertisement featuring the new Capitol Greyhound Terminal, May 19, 1937.

 

Capitol Greyhound Terminal, 1949.

The 50th Street facade of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal, February 26, 1949. The terminal is only 12 years old and is already becoming shabby. Image from flickr.

 

1963 photo of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal.

Looking north towards 51st Street at the westside platforms of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal. This rare color photo shows the blue and buff color brick of the building, circa 1963. Photo from Al Ponte’s Time Machine – New York Facebook page.

The new $300,000 Capitol Greyhound Terminal opened to the public on February 6, 1937. The main waiting room featured a 24 foot ceiling. The side walls were plaster above a terrazzo base and had space for murals. The terrazzo floor featured racing greyhounds out lined by 1/8 inch white metal dividing strips. The ticket, tours and information booths featured burl walnut panels inlaid with strips of ebony separated by ebonized hardwood moldings. The linoleum countertops were edged with an aluminum nosing.

 

Rending of the main waiting room.

Architectural rending of the main waiting room of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal. January, 1937 The Architectural Record. usmodernist.org

 

Second floor mezzanines were at each end of the waiting room. On the second floor were the executive and employee offices on the south side and a balcony lounge on the north side for passengers. The restrooms, baggage storage and air conditioning equipment were located in the basement.

With the completion of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal, bus station construction in mid-Manhattan ended until after the Second World War. Numerous bus terminals in a very densely populated area soon became a major problem.

 

Interior of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal.

Interior of the Capitol Greyhound Terminal, November 1, 1945. The place is empty due to a strike of the Pennsylvania and Central Greyhound Lines. Image from Historic Images via ebay.

 

The 1940’s

With streets already busy with city buses, street cars, taxi cabs and private cars, the addition of hundreds of long distance buses were completely clogging mid-town.  After a particular horrendous traffic situation over the Memorial Day weekend, 1940, city government jumped into action. The city eventually passed an ordinance banning all new bus terminal construction in the area bounded by 22nd and 59th Streets, 8th and Lexington Avenues. In 1940 the city started to propose the construction of a union bus terminal at 9th Avenue and 42nd Street. All the interurban bus companies would use the new terminal with easy access to the Lincoln Tunnel.

 

1940 proposed bus terminal

The proposed bus terminal for 9th Avenue and 42nd Street, New York Herald-Tribune, December 8, 1940.

 

Hugh Ferriss rendering of proposed bus terminal.

Hugh Ferriss rending of the proposed Union Bus Terminal at 42nd Street and 9th Avenue. Image from flickr.com.

 

The city did not get around to building their new terminal until 1949. The following year the Port Authority Bus Terminal opened at 8th Avenue and 40th Street. Shortly there after all the interurban bus companies started to use the new terminal.

 

The Port Authority Bus Terminal, 1950

A post card of the Port Authority Bus Terminal shortly after it opened in 1950. Image from Alamy.com

All that is, except Greyhound, which was in need of a larger and safer terminal. By the late 1940’s their 34th Street terminal had become one of the most crime infested places in mid-town Manhattan. Greyhound wanted to expand their 34th Street terminal and to consolidate the Capitol Greyhound lines into it. With the ban against new bus terminal construction east of 8th Avenue, they could never implement their expansion plans.

 

Finally, on May 17, 1962 Greyhound and the Port Authority reached a deal. Greyhound would move into the Port Authority Bus Terminal in April of 1963 and pay $1,200,000 in annual rent for twenty years. This would give Greyhound 15 berths on the lower level and offices and ticket counters in the upper floors of the terminal.

 

Greyhound moves to the Port Authority.

Greyhound advertisement from The New York Times, May 1, 1963.

With the move into the Port Authority, Greyhound closed the Capitol Bus Terminal. In the summer of 1963 Kinney Systems, a parking lot chain, acquired the former Capitol Greyhound Terminal. The terminal, razed in October 1963, became a parking lot. The following month, Loew’s Inc. took over the site from Kinney with plans to erect an office building on the site. The office building was never built but in 1972 the Uris Theatre  (renamed the Gershwin Theatre in 1983) opened on the former bus terminal plot.

 

The Gershwin Theatre

The Gershwin Theatre on 51st Street, standing on the site once occupied by the Capitol Greyhound Terminal. Image from Wikipedia.

Daabros, a chain of discount department stores, leased the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal in June, 1963. Their plans to convert the former terminal into a store never came to fruition. Exactly when the terminal came down has been lost to time. An aerial photograph taken on July 28, 1965 documenting Pennsylvania Station’s demolition shows the site of the bus terminal as a parking lot. It seems probable that the 34th street Greyhound Terminal did not survive past the end of 1963.

*UPDATED: APRIL 23, 2023

Since this article was published in 2019, I have found evidence that the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal survived past the end of 1963. After Greyhound moved their operations to the Port Authority Bus Terminal in the spring of 1963, the former terminal was converted into a bargain retail store. 

Arthur von Schwertführer photo of West 34th Street in the summer of 1963.

Arthur von Schwertführer photograph of West 34th Street, looking east from 8th Avenue, 1963. The former Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal can be seen on the right after being converted into a retail store. Image from Facebook.

And photos documenting the demolition of Pennsylvania Station show that the former bus terminal did not come down until sometime in 1964, and may have still been standing until early 1965. It was definitely gone by the summer of ’65.

West 33rd Street, April, 1964.

April, 1964: West 33rd Street looking east from 8th Avenue, during the demolition of Pennsylvania Station. The Greyhound Terminal can be seen still standing in the left center of the photo. Photo from Facebook.

Aaron Rose photograph taken from Penn Station during demolition in 1964.

1964 Aaron Rose photograph looking out at West 33rd Street during the demolition of Pennsylvania Station. Greyhound Terminal can be seen across the street. Photograph from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

July 28, 1965. West 34th Street.

July 28, 1965, overhead shot showing the former site of the 34th Street Greyhound Terminal as a parking lot. Image from Newsday / Tom Maguire.

 

Today, the 57 story One Penn Plaza stands on the site of the Pennsylvania Greyhound Terminal. Its construction in the early 1970’s erased all traces of the wonderful streamline moderne terminal that once stood there.

 

One Penn Plaza

One Penn Plaza, standing on the former Greyhound Terminal Sight. Image from Wikipedia.

 

Gone in less than thirty years, not only have Greyhound’s streamline moderne terminals disappeared from New York City, they have disappeared from most people’s memories, too.

 

Anthony & Chris.

Vanished New York City Art Deco: Longchamps

Longchamps matchbook.

Late 1930’s matchbook cover from Longchamps. From the author’s collection.

 

In 1930’s Manhattan a chain of long forgotten restaurants brought café society elegance to the middle class. It all began when wholesaler Henry Lustig opened his first restaurant in 1919 at Madison Avenue and 78th Street. Being a race horse owner, Lustig decided to name his restaurant  Longchamps, after the famous Parisian racecourse. Longchamps specialized in offering an American version of French style cuisine at affordable prices. It met with fast success. By the mid 1920’s the company expanded, opening two new restaurants. One near the recently opened Saks Fifth Avenue, to cash in on the shopping trade.

In mid to late 1930’s the chain rapidly expanded, opening seven restaurants within five years. During this period Longchamps began their relationship with German émigré artist Winold Reiss (1886 – 1953). Reiss’ interior designs in four of these restaurants epitomized modern taste.

 

42nd Street and Lexington Avenue – The Chanin Building

On January 23, 1935 The New York Times announced the plans for the seventh restaurant in the Longchamps chain:

Louis Allen Abramson, architect, filed plans yesterday for an alteration in the Chanin Building, 122 East Forty-second Street. The changes will be made in space in the basement and first floor to be occupied by  a Longchamps Restaurant.

The first floor will be designed as a men’s grill, having an island bar eighty feet in circumference. The improvement will cost $100,000, the architect estimated. – The New York Times, January 23, 1935, Pg. 33. 

 

Winold Reiss, working in collaboration with architect Abramson, transformed the irregular shaped space into something special. Their use of mirrors, lighting, murals and a glamorous staircase combined to create a chic dining atmosphere.

 

Longchamps entrance on 42nd Street, Chanin Building.

Entrance on 42nd Steet to the Longchamps in the Chanin Building, circa 1935. Image from Pinterest.

May 15, 1935 The New York Times reported on the opening:

A new unit in the Longchamps chain of restaurants will be opened today. It occupies space on the ground floor and basement of the Chanin Building at Lexington Avenue and Forty-second Street. A feature of the decorations by Winold Reiss is a series of eight mural panels depicting garden scenes in the time of Louis XIV. – The New York Times, May 15, 1935, Pg. 40.

 

N. Y. Times ad for the new Longchamps.

Advertisement for the Chanin Building Longchamps opening, May 15, 1935. From The New York Times.

 

A few days later the New York Post enthusiastically wrote:

AN ART, EATING – AT LONGCHAMPS

Glittering Lexington Avenue Restaurant’s a Feast to Eye as Well as Palate

When epicures die they may go to heaven but in the meantime they can always go to Longchamps, and especially the last and most glittering of the Longchamps restaurants in the Chanin Building on Lexington Avenue. 

It is a feast to the eye as well as the palate. The decor, we are told is based on that gayest and most wicked of periods in French history, the time before the Revolution when the courts were at their best and worst, when living was lavish and high and handsome.

And that is just the feeling that one gets on entering the cocktail salon of this Longchamps. The colors are vermilion, black and white, and it is safe to say you will never go out the same man!

A Vista of Gardens

A grand staircase leads to the dining room below, and at a turn of the stairs a vista of sunlit gardens is spread before your eyes. The famous designer, Winold Reiss, certainly knows his French gardens and has produced them to the life in the murals that encompass the room. – New York Post, May 19, 1935. Pg. 6

 

 

Bar at the Chanin Building's Longchamps

Winold Reiss’ Louis XV mural behind the Chanin Building’s Longchamps bar. Photograph by Robert M. Damora. Image from winoldreiss.org

 

Mural detail. Chanin Building Longchamps.

Louis XV Mural 6′ x 6′ 4″ section. Image from winoldreiss.org

Upon its opening in May of 1935 the Chanin Building Longchamps was one of the largest restaurants in the area. The following year the New York Herald-Tribune reported:

 

Longchamps Chain to Occupy Additional Unit

The Restaurant Longchamps, which operated a unit in the Chanin Building, Lexington Avenue and Forty-second Street, have leased as additional space the store and basement at the southwest corner of the thoroughfares now occupied by Broadstreet’s. The enlarged restaurant will compare favorably in size of both restaurant and bar facilities with the chain’s new unit under construction at Broadway and Forty-first Street. – New York Herald-Tribune, June 9, 1936, Pg. 41.

 

The same day The New York Sun reporting on the expansion remarked that the enlargement would make the restaurant the largest in the Grand Central District. By the time the renovations on East Forty-second were underway a new and even larger Longchamps was nearing completion across town on West Forty-first street.

 

41st Street & Broadway

 

41st Street and Broadway Longchamps around 1937.

Longchamps restaurant at Broadway and 41st Street, circa 1937. Image from nyneon.blogspot.com.

 

Located in Ely Jacques Kahn’s Continental Building (1931), the new restaurant would be as modern as the building. For the decorative scheme inside this Longchamps Reiss chose to honor New York City’s past, present and future. Unfortunately there are not too many photographs that exist of the interior at this location. The news of the latest restaurant hit the papers on March 15, 1936:

Longchamps Restaurant Takes Lease of Street Floor in Continental Building

Longchamps announced yesterday it will open a branch restaurant in the Continental Building at the south-east corner of Broadway and Forty-first Street, in the Times Square section. The restaurant will be ready for the opening  of the theatrical season next fall. The entire interior of the premises will be made over. It was said yesterday that the restaurant will provide accommodation for 1,500 persons at one time. One feature of the new restaurant will be an oval-shaped bar which will be 200 feet long, one of the longest continuous drinking platforms in the city. More than 500 waiters, chefs, barmen and others will be employed in the establishment which, it was said yesterday, may be opened night and day. – New York Herald-Tribune, March 15, 1936, Pg. 11

 

Opening day ad from the New York Times.

New York Times advertisement for the opening day of the new Longchamps, describing the various NYC themes of the different rooms. Image from proquest.com

 

By late April with the awarding of construction contracts, alterations of the space began for the $500,000 restaurant. Architect Louis Allen Abramson created an outdoor cafe effect on the main floor by having the walls along Broadway and Forty-first street and the revolving door lowered to sub-street level. Of course the lowering of the walls only occurred during warm weather months. This proved popular and a couple of future Longchamps also included descending walls.

 

Longchamps_41st & Broadway_Walls and Door Up

The Broadway facade at night, with the revolving door and windows in their up position. Photograph by Zimmerman. Image from Architectural Record, December, 1937. Downloadable from usmodernist.org

 

Descending walls diagram.

Diagram of the descending walls and revolving door. Image from Architectural Record, December, 1937. Downloadable from usmodernist.org

 

Longchamps_41st & Broadway_Walls down.

Zimmerman photograph of the 41st Longchamps showing the Broadway facade with the walls lowered. Image from Architectural Record, December, 1937. Downloadable from usmodernist.org

Like the last Longchamps, Winold Reiss received the commission for the interior design at the Forty-first Street location. Modern and contemporary throughout with silk batik and a series of murals by Reiss. These blue, white and gold murals would depict future Manhattan.

 

City of the Future Mural

 

Album Room_Longchamps_41st

The Album Room of the Broadway and Forty-first Street Longchamps. Portraits of famous New Yorkers of the past, such as Lillian Russell and Diamond Jim Brady hung on the walls. Photograph by Robert Damora.

Abramson’s bold ceiling employed curves and levels. While giving the Album Room a very modern aesthetic, it also concealed the cove lighting. The ceiling curves matched those on the floor by mimicking the sinuous half wall (to divide seating areas) and steps.

 

Album Room Ceiling Detail.

Album Room ceiling detail showing mirrored column and cove lighting. Photograph by Robert Damora.

 

The new Longchamps opened its doors on October 13, 1936.  Due to its proximity to the Broadway Theatres and the Metropolitan Opera, it found immediate popularity. The following day The New York Times reported:

30 MEN TEND HUGE BAR

New Restaurant in Times Square Also Has Vast Wine Cellar.

One of the largest restaurants in the Times Square district, the tenth in the Longchamps chain, was opened last night in the Broadway Continental Building, with business executives and celebrities of the stage and screen in attendance.

New York’s growth and old favorites of Broadway are recalled in the murals and decorations of the restaurant, which features a wine cellar with a capacity of 120,000 bottles and an oval bar with thirty bartenders. 

In the cocktail lounge, murals depict important scenes in New York’s history and in the adjoining rooms, “dedicated to the twentieth and twenty-first centuries.” are large murals designed to show the city of the future. The Album on New Yorkers’ Room contains portraits of celebrities, including O. Henry, Florenze Ziegfeld and David Belasco.  – The New York Times, October 14, 1936, Pg. 28.

Several days later the New York Herald-Tribune had this to say:

New Longchamps a Smash

Record crowds (6,700 for luncheon alone) attended the opening of the new Longchamps at Broadway and Forty-first Street, Tuesday. The restaurant boasts air-conditioned kitchen and telephone booths, a huge oval bar and a glass street front that can be lowered on an elevator shaft. – New York Herald-Tribune, October 17, 1936, Pg. 8

 

Typical Menu, 1938

 

253 Broadway

 

253 Broadway Longchamps.

The eleventh Longchamps at 253 Broadway, across from City Hall, 1938. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

Across lower Broadway from City Hall the eleventh Longchamps became the most expensive and largest restaurant built-in New York City to date. Occupying space in the basement and first three floors of the 1892 Paragon Building, major structural changes were necessary to accommodate the restaurant. This Longchamps would be a “five-in-one”, meaning there were five separate restaurant units at this site. This new location could seat 1,163 people at one time.  Total cost of construction and interior design, $1,000,000, a first for the city.

 

Main entrance detail. Longchamps at 253 Broadway

Detail of the main entrance to the Longchamps at 253 Broadway. This shows the restaurant with the front wall lowered to create the sidewalk cafe effect. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

Winold Reiss using over 2,000 square feet of wall space for murals, the decorative theme according to The New York Times:

. . . will be an interweaving of the types, customs and costumes of the nations of the world. The theme is intended to portray the international relationships with which the location traditionally has been associated. – The New York Times, July 21, 1937, Pg. 40

 

Reiss' main mural for the Longchamps at 253 Broadway.

Winold Reiss’ huge two story mural just inside the main entrance to the restaurant. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

At this Longchamps and the following one Reiss worked in collaboration with famed New York City architect Ely Jacques Kahn. Kahn arranged the almost acre of space into a series of connected terraces. The terraces were arranged in such a way to allow views of the restaurant from any of the floors. This included the lifting of part of the second floor for the creation of a new mezzanine level.

 

 

Like all the recent Longchamps this one was a showcase of modern design. Black vitrolite and two stories of glass block crowned the main entrance. The use of the glass block flooded the second floor with natural light.

 

Second floor on the Broadway side of the restaurant.

Third level interior showing the glass block front wall. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

Other modern amenities would include complete air conditioning with an ionization plant to supposedly charge the air with a lively freshness, indirect lighting and an acoustical treatment to bring a quietness to the dining rooms.

 

Indirect lighting fixture

Indirect lighting fixture and mirrored wall in the “Restaurant of the Old World” Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

A dinner for 1,500 guests formally opened the restaurant on March 22, 1938. Among the guests were former New York State governor Al Smith and the  models  who posed for the murals by Winold Reiss that adorned the walls. These models were present in the costumes that they wore in the murals and included a Chickahominy native from Virginia, girls from Tibet and Tahiti, a Utah cowgirl, a native of Sicily and citizens from several countries all who were living in New York at the time.

 

On the ground floor the “Snug Harbor Bar” dominated the south side of the restaurant. Even though “snug” was part of the name there was nothing snug about the very long bar running almost the entire length of the establishment. A novel feature was the lighting underneath the front edge illuminating the outside of the bar.

 

Ground Floor 1

Back area of the “Snug Harbor Bar”, showing the indirect lighting above the bar. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

Placed down in the basement the “Westward Ho! Grill” decorated in knotty pine provided a secluded area to dine and enjoy a cocktail. Lining one wall of the grill a mural depicting 15th Century ships sailing off to the New World gave the room its decorative theme.

 

Stairs down to the basement.

Staircase from the ground floor down to the Westward Ho! Grill in the basement. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

 

 

Bar in the Westward Ho! Grill.

The bar in the “Westward Ho! Grill”. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

A boldly painted staircase with a huge mural led up from the ground floor to the “Flying Bridge Cafe” on the newly built mezzanine level and the second floor.

 

Main staircase.

The staircase and mural leading up to the “Flying Bridge Cafe” on the mezzanine. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

 

 

 

 

"Flying Bridge Cafe"

Looking down to the ground floor from the “Flying Bridge Cafe”. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

Continuing up the stairs from the “Flying Bridge Cafe” would take one to the third level where there were two more additional dining rooms. The dining space at the very top of the stairs was known as the “Far Eastern Terrace”.

 

Looking towards the back of the "Far Eastern Terrace."

The stairs going the the third level and the “Far Eastern Terrace’. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

 

The balance of the third level was taken up by “the Restaurant of the Old World”. This largest single dining space in the restaurant had murals by Reiss depicting the peoples and the customs of Europe.

 

 

Restaurant of the Old World 3

Back section of the “Restaurant of the Old World”. Ezra Stoller photograph from esto.com

 

Like all the previous restaurants in the Longchamps chain this one was another success. While the first customers were filing into 253 Broadway in March of 1938, a 12th Longchamps was already under construction in the most famous building in the world.

 

The Empire State Building

1931, The Empire State Building

The Empire State Building, circa 1931. Image from NYPL Digital Collections.

The 12th and last Longchamps to open in the 1930’s was another collaboration between artist Winold Reiss and architect Ely Jacques Kahn. Unlike the previous Longchamps decorated by Reiss, the one in the Empire State Building would not have a particular theme, like pre-revolutionary France in the Chanin Building Longchamps or old world / new world in the one on lower Broadway near City Hall. The New York Sun reported on December 15, 1937 that Longchamps took a 21 year lease for space at the 5th Avenue and Thirty-fourth street corner of the Empire State Building. The space which had been vacant since the building opened in 1931, would be converted into an ultra modern restaurant with a seating capacity for 1,000.

 

Love Affair (1939)

Extras at the RKO studio in front of a rear projection screen in the 1939 film Love Affair. A corner of Longchamps can be seen in the background. Image from DVD.

 

The new restaurant occupied the entire northeast section of the first floor, basement and sub-basement. Missing the originally announced opening date of May 1st, Al Smith, president of Empire State, Inc. opened the restaurant on September 21, 1938. Smith said in his welcoming speech that he believed “the architecture, decoration, service and food will do much to uphold the fine standards of Fifth Avenue and the Empire State area.”

 

It is especially noticeable at this Longchamps the changing style of interior decoration. Today, while this is still considered Art Deco, it comes near the end of that design era. Gone is the crazy exuberance and harsh angles of the 1920’s. By 1938 a new European influence is evident, popularized at the Exposition Internationale des Arts et Techniques dans la Vie Moderne held in Paris, 1937. Design elements are softer, dominated by biomorphic forms and curves.

 

Winold Reiss_Empire State_Longchamps

Winold Reiss sitting at a table beneath one of his murals in the lower level of the Empire State’s Longchamps. Ezra Stoller photographer. Image from winoldreiss.org.

 

An exuberantly painted bar greeted patrons on the ground floor. From there a large dining room filled the space at street level. To get down to lower levels a wide steel and mirror lined staircase led to the basement. Reiss continued the vermillion, cream and gold Longchamp color scheme at this latest location.

 

Ground floor bar.

Ground floor bar. Ezra Stoller photograph from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

 

Ground floor dining room.

The dining room on the ground floor. Ezra Stoller photograph from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

 

Staircase to lower level.

The mirror lined staircase leading to the lower level dining area. Ezra Stoller photograph from the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.

 

 

With the opening of the Empire State location the Longchamps chain reached its peak.  Winold Reiss continued to receive commissions from Longchamps into the 1940’s and 1950’s for locations in New York City and else where. But after suffering a stroke in 1951 Reiss’ output would be greatly reduced. On August 23, 1953 Reiss died in New York City. As for Longchamps its fortunes would start to change after the Second World War.

 

Post Second World War

It seems that Longchamps proprietor, Henry Lustig, started cheating the IRS in 1940. An audit in 1945 revealed that he and two of his associates had evaded paying $2,872,766.00 in taxes to the government. Brought to trial in May, 1946 the case reached a verdict on June 20 of that year. When sentenced on July 10th, Lustig had to pay $115,000.00 fine and received a four-year jail term.

 

Henry Lustig

Henry Lustig, 1946 at the time of his tax evasion trial. Photo from the New York Herald-Tribune.

In 1947 the government sold all of Longchamps stock to Valley Trust Co., nominee for the Springfield newspaper pension trusts and its subsidiary, Exchange Buffet Corp. Through the 1950’s Longchamps annual sales ran between $7,000,000.00 and $8,000,000.00 but lost money every year, except 1954 when it made a small profit of $7,258.00. Restaurateur Jan Mitchell acquired Longchamps in early 1959. He believed that the chain still held great potential. In 1950 Mitchell purchased the famous German restaurant, Luchow’s on 14th Street in Manhattan and tripled its business by the end of the decade.

 

Jan Mitchell at Luchow's in 1958.

Jan Mitchell serving up good cheer at Luchow’s in 1958. Photograph from The New York Times.

Beginning with the new decade it would be out with the old and in with the “Olde Tyme”. The interior decorations that were so modern and chic in the 1930’s had become tired and dated by 1960. The first change came to the lower level at the Longchamps in the Empire State Building. In honor of Luchows, Mitchell converted Reiss’ dining room into a Bavarian brauhaus. Martin Burden in his “Going Out Tonight? . . .” column in the New York Post described the room this way:

. . . the big terraced downstairs area becomes the Karneval Room, a gay and pleasant rathskeller. It stresses hearty German foods, big steins of imported beer, an oom-pa-pa band clad in lederhosen to provide the music, everything from ‘Ach, du Lieber Augustine’ to ‘You Are My Sunshine. There are souvenir hats, community sings, beer barrels, red-and-white checkered tablecloths, brightly colored paper streamers, huge confetti balls. Its cheery atmosphere should provide a fine attraction in the midtown section.  – New York Post, February 9, 1960, Pg. 51.

 

The Teutonic gaiety didn’t last very long and in the early months of 1964 the entire Empire State Longchamps underwent a complete renovation. And on April 16, 1964  “sailing” into the Empire State Building was Mark Twain’s Riverboat Restaurant. Do not be confused by the name, Mark Twain was not personally affiliated with the restaurant in any way.

 

Newspaper ad, 1964.

Newspaper ad for the opening of Mark Twain’s Riverboat Restaurant. New York World-Telegram & Sun, April 15, 1964.

Now instead of offering classic Longchamp dishes, like sizzling platters or crepe suzette, one could order “Good Vittles”. And why enjoy just a regular old style cocktail when “Hard Likker” was now being offered which one might need to drown out all the “banjos a-plunkin'”. In his “Tips on Tables” in the New York World-Telegram & Sun, Bob Dana had this to say of the renovated restaurant:

Tuneful Debut For Riverboat

The Mark Twain Riverboat Restaurant, inspired by the life and works of the beloved American author, will be unveiled by Jan Mitchell tomorrow at Longchamps in the Empire State Building. There will be dancing to the music of Stan Rubin and his Riverboat Ramblers, with additional music by a costumed banjo group, which will promenade through both levels of the restaurant. 

Stage designer Oliver Smith has designed the restaurant, the main floor  of which is largely a recreation of a dining saloon of a steamer that Mark Twain might have piloted down the Mississippi. Adjacent to the dining room are remainders of the high-stake gambling that flourished on riverboats; the Gaming Room and Gambler’s Den. Over the deep mirrored stairwell leading to the lower floor is a large revolving replica of a paddlewheel, gleaning in the reflection of lights that outline a huge horseshoe bar. 

A large selection of dishes, adapted from foods popular along the Mississippi of Mark Twain’s day, have been added to the extensive Longchamps menu. – New York World-Telegram & Sun, April 15, 1964, Pg. 36.

 

The renovated restaurant proving to be a hit, inspiring more Longchamps renovations the next year. Oliver Smith transformed the Art Deco spaces into 1960’s versions of nostalgia. The Chanin Building’s pre-revolutionary France theme was out. Now a railroad decor took its place, due to the proximity of Grand Central Terminal across the street.

 

Jan Mitchell, 1967.

Jan Mitchell introduces Longchamps chef, John van Hooff to Irving and Murray Riese the new owners of the Longchamps chain, 1967. John Orris photograph from The New York Times.

When Mitchell sold the chain to the Riese Brothers in 1967 the end was in sight. The Riese Corporation already purchased another famous New York City chain, Childs, now they swallowed Longchamps.  By 1970 only one restaurant in the chain still operated under the Longchamps name. The holding company Longchamps, Inc. formally dissolved in 1975.

 

Like so much of New York City’s past, Longchamps has vanished not only from the city but from most people’s memories. Which is a shame, for it was the most stylish of all the city’s eateries.

 

Matchbook inside.

The inside of a matchbook from Longchamps, late 1930’s. From the collection of the author.

 

Anthony & Chris (The Freakin’, Tiquen’ Guys)

If you enjoyed this post you might also like these earlier posts:

Vanished New York City Art Deco: The Persian Room

The Central Park Casino, Joseph Urban’s Long, Lost New York City Night Club