Category Archives: Architecture

The Spot for Some Art Deco in Rochester, New York

Spot Coffee

Spot Coffee at 200 East Avenue. Rochester, New York

 

I’ve written a few posts on Art Deco in Manhattan, but not anything about Rochester, New York my home since 2001. Truth said, there’s not much Art Deco in Rochester. But there is some and SPoT Coffee is one of those places. SPoT is located in a great Streamline Moderne former Chevrolet dealership. SPoT Coffee a Toronto based firm opened the Rochester Branch in the late 1990s. The building, at 200 East Avenue dates back to 1911 and by the late 1920s housed the Sergeant Ford dealership.

 

East Avenue Rochester New York, circa 1930.

East Avenue looking west, circa 1930. Sergeant Ford dealership at right, center of the photo. Image from Monroe Country Library System Digital Collections.

As seen in the photograph above the building’s original design was in Arts and Crafts style. The walls were of a dark concrete with a light brick trim. The Mathews Street façade not modernized in the 1930s still has the original design.

 

Mathews Street facade of SPoT Coffee.

SPoT Coffee Mathews Street Facade. This side of the building did not receive the 1930’s Vitrolite modernization.

The conversion from Arts and Crafts to Streamline Moderne took place in 1937. The 1936 Rochester City Director still lists Sergeant Motors being at 200 East Avenue. The 1937 directory does not list a business at that address. By 1938 Central Chevrolet had moved to Sergeant Motor’s former building.

The East Avenue side of SPoT Coffee.

SPoT Coffee’s East Avenue frontage.

The East Avenue frontage was completely covered in black vitrolite and a huge semi-circular window installed. Red neon Chevrolet signs, a neon clock and ribbed stainless steel  pilasters and mullions completed the new exterior.

 

 

The interior received an up to date (for 1937) streamline make over, too. The original interior design was a restrained classical style with octagonal, modified doric columns and a coffered ceiling. While the columns survived the moderne make over the sidewalls went streamline.

 

SPoT Coffee interior

SPoT Coffee interior Showing details of the original columns and ceiling and the streamline remodel of the office, with blue glass wrap around windows and stainless steel moulding.

The chrome banding and the wrap around blue glass windows typify the modern style of the mid to late 1930s. A style that would be coming to an end by the start of the Second World War.

 

SPoT Coffee interior

The interior of SPoT Coffee. Looking down on the main floor from the balcony.

 

SPoT Coffee Chandelier.

Streamline chandelier with mid-century down light attachments.

The chandeliers are almost pure Art Deco. They feature chrome banding, fluted rods attached to brushed aluminum discs that sandwich clear glass balls. There are 14 lights sticking out from the chandelier’s center. While the rods holding the lights seem original to the fixture, the lights themselves look like 1950’s replacements.

Chandelier detail.

Close up view of one of SPoT Coffee’s Chandeliers. Photo taken from the balcony.

Ceiling fan.

In addition to the chandeliers, there are a couple of “futuristic” ceiling fans cooling off the coffee shop.

When Central Chevrolet opened in 1937-1938 the manager was Maynard Hallman. Hallman eventually acquired the dealership sometime in the early 1950s and renamed the business Hallman Chevrolet. First Team bought the Hallman’s in 1986. Then after unsuccessfully trying to find a buyer for the dealership, First Team closed Hallman’s in 1990.

 

While still on the market, the Landmark Society of Western New York wanted to get landmark designation for the closed Hallman’s dealership in 1991. Because of the restrictions to landmark buildings, First Team was against the designation. First Team also claimed that the Art Deco makeover was a later addition to the 1911 building. So the building sat empty. Then in 1995 the city of Rochester took a $900,000 option on the old dealership building.

Eventually the building received landmark status and in 2000 SPoT Coffee moved in. Originally SPoT had the entire showroom space. In 2011 the main floor was divided and now a Bubble Fusion and Japanese cuisine and tea restaurant moved into the eastern half of the building. An original showroom feature is the Vitrolite glass and chrome fireplace. And the same chrome stripping along the walls and ceiling lights.

 

Bubble Fusion fireplace.

Vitrolite glass and chrome fireplace in Bubble Tea on East Avenue. Image from yelp.

So should you be in downtown Rochester and you find yourself in a need for a good dose of Art Deco, or coffee, or sushi, make sure you stop in at SPoT Coffee or Bubble Fusion.

 

East Avenue Facade.

The East Avenue facade of the former Central / Hallman’s Chevrolet. Now home to SPot Coffee and Bubble Fusion.

 

Anthony (One half of the Freakin’, ‘Tiquen Guys)

Vanished New York City Art Deco – The Persian Room

The Persian Room in the Plaza Hotel

The Persian Room of the Plaza Hotel, 1934. Image from cooperhewitt.org

At 5:32 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, December 5, 1933,  Utah became the 36th state to ratify the 21st amendment to the Constitution. With the requisite three-fourth states majority, prohibition came to an end after 13 years, 10 months and 19 days. The era of the speakeasy was over, the era of swank nightclubs was about to begin and “café society” born.

 

Plaza Hotel, 1907.

The Plaza Hotel looking southwest from 5th Avenue and 60th Street, 1907. Image from mcny.org

The Plaza Hotel opening in 1907 typified the Beaux-Arts style so popular in the first decade of the 20th Century. For the next two and half decades the Plaza represented Edwardian respectability.

 

Small dining room of the Plaza Hotel.

Small dining room in the Plaza Hotel, 1907. Very typical of the Edwardian Era. Image from mcny.org.

1934

Now that prohibition was a thing of the past, the management of the Plaza wanted a new space to attract the night life crowd; a space to compete against nightclubs, like The Stork Club, El Morocco and The Central Park CasinoThe New York Times announced the plan for the nightclub on January 31, 1934:

Hotel Plaza Plans New Cocktail Room

Corner at 5th Av. and 58th St. Will be Fitted Up at Cost of $50,000.

The Plaza Operating Company filed plans with the Building Department yesterday for a new cocktail room in the south corner of the Hotel Plaza, at Fifth Avenue and Fifty-eighth Street.  The new room will contain a service bar and dance floor and will cost $50,000.

Four windows will face on the east overlooking the Plaza, from which side there will be a special entrance. Other approaches will be from the lobby of the hotel and from the Palm Court.. The  new room will be known as the Persian Room and will be designed and decorated by the Joseph Urban Associates.

Five murals reminiscent of old Persians miniatures are being designed by Lillian Gaertner Palmedo for this room, which will seat from 250 to 300 persons.  A twenty-seven-foot bar will adorn the west wall and on the south side of the room there will be raised orchestra platform for about fifteen musicians.

 

Lillian Gaertner Palmedo with one of the five murals to adorn the Persian Room.

Lillian Gaertner Palmedo putting the finishing touches on one of the five murals that gave the Persian Room its name. Image from Getty Images.

As the article in the Times reported, Joseph Urban Associates undertook the job of designing the new nightclub. Joseph Urban one of the most famous designers in the United States in the 1920’s and 1930’s had designed the Ziegfeld Theatre and The Central Park Casino among many other famous buildings in New York had died the previous May. His company certainly kept his aesthetic alive in the Persian Room. The oval shape of the ceiling as well as the use of black carrara glass and gold panels is more than just a little reminiscent of Urban’s design of the Urban Room in Pittsburgh. Less than four months from the announcement of the new club the room opened to the public.

Herald-Tribune photo of Persian Room mural.

Detail of one of the Persian Room’s murals. Photo from The New York Herald-Tribune, March 18, 1934.

Scheduled for an early April opening, Vogue Magazine of April 1, 1934 described the new night spot this way:

Consider, for instance, the Plaza, which for years has been as nobly aloof from the jazz age as the professionally quaint cab drivers outside its door. Well, the Plaza is stepping out to meet a new life. On the second of April, it is opening a brand-new room, called the Persian Room because of the subtly intricate Persian murals designed by the Joseph Urban Associates. The proceeds of the grand gala will go to the New York Infirmary. In the Persian Room, you will see a New York that is not (thank God!) Lillian-Russell-Bustanoby’s-Diamond-Jim-Brady any more than it is the New York of the speakeasy era.

You can’t describe the atmosphere, because there is nothing with which to compare it. Certainly, the room has nothing to do with the marbled, potted-palm lobby which lies outside its door. The Persian Room is a sport, a freak, an anachronism. Only a very great lady could afford to be so whimsical and so disdainful of tradition. The room is, in short, New York in the spring of 1934. A bar and café and (when the occasion demands) a supper room with space for orchestra and dancing. It overlooks the Plaza and is as modern – with concealed flood-lighting (each table top is specially illuminated), a white-and-red colour scheme, and a metal-and-ebony bar – as you could ask. The lighting alone is worth going a considerable distance to see, and, if the ghost of Mr. Urban ever walks, it might well drop in at the Persian Room and look things over: the chances are it would approve.

 

Entrance to the Persian Room, 1934.

The Persian Room’s interior entrance way from the lobby, 1934. Image from cooperhewitt.org

 

After it’s April 2nd gala opening night, the Persian Room became one of the most successful New York City Night clubs. Many top performers appeared there in the forty-one years it was open. But the original decor would not last even a decade.

 

Seagram Whiskey ad, 1935 featuring the Persian Room.

Seagram’s Whiskey advertisement showing a color rendition of the original Persian Room. From the January 1, 1935 edition of Vogue.

Entrance way to the Persian Room, 1934.

Persian Room entrance way, 1934. Image from nypl.org.

Bergdoff Goodman ad using the Persian Room as a backdrop. Vogue Magazine.

Bergdoff Goodman advertisement using the Persian Room as a backdrop. Vogue Magazine, October 15, 1934.

 

When the Persian Room closed for the summer in 1942, its decor so chic and modern in 1934, seemed very dated. The Art Deco gave way to what we now call “Hollywood Regency”. Gone were four of five murals and black carrara glass. Legendary café society performer Hildegarde reopened the re-modeled Persian Room in late September, 1942. L. L. Stevenson in his syndicated column Lights of New York reported on October 31, 1942 wrote the following about the new decor:

In honor of the advent of Hildegarde, the Persian Room, for the second time since it opened in 1934, has undergone a complete change in decor and minor change in arrangement. The noted Lillian Gaertner Palmedo Persian murals are still over the bandstand, but little else remains of the past. A terrace, with a balustrade and a full-length banquette, has been built along the Fifth Avenue side, reducing the capacity of the room from 300 to 275, and thus making it that much more intimate.

The 1942 Re-Model

 

Malcolm Johnson’s, September 29, 1942 “Cafe Life in New York” column in The New York Sun had this to say about the new Persian Room:

It is enough to say that its new dress, with egg shell white as the dominant motif, is bright and cheerful and quite unlike any thing the Persian Room has worn before. Only one of the famous murals remains – the one over the bandstand – and the room has been terraced to command a better view of the floor than in the past.

1950

Even this “new” Persian Room would not last a decade. Conrad Hilton purchased the Plaza Hotel in 1943. In 1950 Hilton contacted famed industrial and interior designer Henry Dreyfuss to discuss plans about a complete renovation of the space. Dreyfuss, writing in his 1955 book, Designing for People, said this about his redesign of the Persian Room:

More than appearance is involved in remodeling and redecorating a night club. The industrial designer must think also in terms of air conditioning, lighting, easy access for the waiters through the crowded tables, acoustics, fire exits – but always glamour. The most popular night spots are those in which lighting magically erases wrinkles and double chins, making dowagers look like debutantes and tired merchants feel like Olympic champions.

Our examination of the room recalled the excavations of the site of ancient Troy. Four successive designers over a period of forty years had imposed their ideas on the room, but, unfortunately, the last three had not bothered to remove the previous interiors, which nested one inside the other. In order to enlarge the capacity and satisfy a critical municipal building code and fire department, the four interiors were removed, and we got a fresh start from the brick walls. We settled on a diagonal plan that would give every seat a good view. The bandstand, therefore, was placed in one corner and everything fanned out from it.

Our design was contemporary, but with a Persian motif chosen because of the famous name of the room, and for this we visited museums and haunted the Iranian Institute, reading the lore of Iran and studying Persian temples and miniatures. The Persian Room has eight enormous windows twenty feet high on two of its walls. For these we had curtains woven of deep blue and green with metallic strands.

Alice Hughes in her September 29, 1950 Buffalo Courier Express column wrote:

New York, Sept. 28 – Tonight’s the night when the jogalong horse-and-buggy pace of the Hotel Plaza is jet-propelled into this new electronic world. It’s the night of the opening of the fabulous new Persian Room, the Plaza’s cafe, rebuilt and recreated this past Summer by Henry Dreyfuss. He is the industrial architect whose designs went into the American Export luxury liners Constitution and Independence, also the new 20th Century Limited, also the erstwhile New York World’s Fair exhibits. What he has created for the Persian Room is a secret until tonight. That it will surpass most going night clubs is without doubt for Dreyfuss is a superb designer.

 

The 1950 remodeled Persian Room by Henry Dreyfuss.

Henry Dreyfuss’ remodel of the Persian Room, 1950. image from theplazany.com

 

“Mid-Century Modern” is the best way to describe the new decor. And in this design the Persian Room would thrive for the next decade-and-half. But in the late 1960’s the era of the super club came to an end.  The Persian Room closed for good in 1975. A dress shop went into the space that formerly hosted some of the top entertainers in American show business. Today the Rose Club occupies the space and it fits in nicely with the rest of the Plaza Hotel stylistically.

 

The Rose Club.

The Rose Club at the Plaza Hotel and a return to Edwardian elegance, now occupies the space of the Persian Room. Image from Google.

But lets end with one last look at the original Persian Room. The very short-lived elegant club that ushered in a new era just after the end of Prohibition.

 

The western end of the original Persian Room.

The western side of the original Persian Room showing the 27 foot-long bar and three of the Palmedo murals, 1934. Photo from nypl.org

 

Anthony & Chris (The Freakin’, ‘Tiquen Guys)